The 10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Loganville & Grayson, GA

Whether you're a deep-dish devotee, a fan of crispy thin crust, or someone who loves building your own pie from scratch, the Loganville–Grayson area offers a variety of great spots to satisfy your pizza cravings. From artisan ovens to chain favorites, here's a definitive guide to the top 10 pizza places in the area — ranked by taste, atmosphere, and local reputation.

 

---

1. Your Pie – Loganville

911 Atlanta Hwy, Loganville, GA 30052

🔥 Why it's #1: Your Pie isn’t just a pizza place—it’s a personalized culinary experience. With its hand-tossed dough, house-made sauces, and unlimited toppings, you build your own brick oven pizza just the way you like it. Gluten-free, keto, and vegan options are available, and you can pair your pie with local craft beer or finish your meal with creamy gelato. The atmosphere is modern, casual, and perfect for both families and date nights.

 

---

2. Johnny’s New York Style Pizza - Loganville

910 Athens Hwy Ste A, Loganville, GA 30052
🍕 Why it's #2: A local favorite for big, foldable New York slices, Johnny’s serves up bold flavor with a nostalgic pizzeria vibe. Known for their garlic knots, calzones, and generous portions, this spot hits all the right notes for those who crave that authentic NY-style crust with the perfect chew.

 

---

3. Johnny’s New York Style Pizza – Grayson

1911 Grayson Hwy Ste 9, Grayson, GA 30017
🍝 Why it's #3: This Johnny’s location is just as strong, offering the same great menu with fast service and a comfortable setting. It's ideal for lunch breaks, takeout, or a casual night out. Their calzones and meat lover’s pies are especially popular with locals.

 

---

4. Marco’s Pizza – Grayson

1911 Grayson Hwy Ste 13, Grayson, GA 30017
🧀 Marco’s earns its spot with quality ingredients and robust flavor. The crust is slightly thicker than average, and the cheese blend and signature sauce hit all the right notes. If you're ordering for a group, their specialty pizzas and cheesy breadsticks are crowd-pleasers.

 

---

5. Pizza Hut - Loganville

3949 Atlanta Hwy, Loganville, GA 30052
🍕 The classic pan pizza still holds up. Pizza Hut in Loganville offers one of the few dine-in experiences among national chains, making it a great place to bring the family. Bonus points for stuffed crust and their sweet cinnamon sticks.

 

---

6. Domino’s - Loganville

4685 Atlanta Hwy, Loganville, GA 30052
🚗 When you need pizza fast and done right, Domino’s delivers—literally and figuratively. With robust app ordering, regular deals, and crispy thin crust options, it's a go-to for weeknight dinners and late-night cravings.

 

---

7. Papa John’s – Loganville

3975 Atlanta Hwy, Loganville, GA 30052
🧄 Known for its signature garlic sauce and pepperoncini on every order, Papa John’s is a consistent choice for pizza lovers who like a sweeter tomato sauce and chewy crust. Quick delivery and frequent discounts add to its appeal.

 

---

8. Domino’s – Grayson

1915 Grayson Hwy Ste 7, Grayson, GA 30017
🔥 Domino’s Grayson location stands out for reliable service and accurate orders. It’s not flashy, but it’s a workhorse when you need something fast and satisfying.

 

---

9. Papa John’s - Grayson

1142 Athens Hwy Ste 105, Grayson, GA 30045
📦 A solid pick for carryout or delivery, this Papa John’s gets good reviews for fresh pies and quick turnaround. Their thin crust and stuffed crust options give it a slight edge over some of the competition.

 

---

10. Little Caesar's - Loganville

910 Athens Hwy, Loganville, GA 30052
🍕 Why it made the list: While not gourmet, Little Caesars earns its spot for one reason: value and speed. Their Hot-N-Ready pizzas are perfect for quick meals, feeding kids, or grabbing something cheap and easy. The Loganville location is clean, efficient, and rarely keeps you waiting.

 

---

Final Slice

 

From custom-built masterpieces at Your Pie to no-frills classics at Johnny’s, the pizza scene in Loganville and Grayson is diverse and delicious. Whether you're feeding a family, grabbing takeout, or sitting down for a slice with friends, these top 10 pizza spots offer something for everyone.

 

Hungry yet? 🍕 Let us know your favorite pie in the area—and if we missed a hidden gem, we’re always ready for another slice!